Fears Of A Canadian Real Estate Bubble May Be Unfounded

The forecasts for a nationwide Canadian housing bubble have thus far not become reality, and the housing sector has remained robust throughout the mortgage crisis that rocked the U. S. economy the last few years. Analysts were concerned that the Canada Mortgage and Housing Corporation's (CMHC) plan to keep the credit circulating by authorizing high-risk loans had produced a disturbing 7.4:1 ratio of income to real estate values -- almost 50 percent more than the American ratio prior to the U.S. housing bubble collapse. As a result of the CMHC's policy change, the average Canadian family debt experienced a 9.3 percent raise in only one year.

Earlier this year, Stephen Jarislowsky -- the 84-year-old investment consultant presumably worth $1.85 billion -- said to reporters that the CMHC's plan had backfired. In a phone interview, Jarislowsky flatly negated assertions by Finance Minister Jim Flaherty that there appeared to be no evidence of an upcoming real estate bubble.  Jarislowsky firmly believed that the government's programs were not going to strengthen the economy. In a phone interview, he said that the CMHC "..has created the reverse effect of what was desirable. "They have basically encouraged people to buy properties based on cheap mortgages..and that has created the opposite effect of what was advisable." This can be witnessed in the City of Toronto where the prices of Toronto properties as risen by quite a bit over the years as buyers rushed into the market.

In February, the Wall Street Journal investigated the possibility of a Canadian real estate bubble and highlighted that bold lending practices adopted after the 2008 collapse of the U.S. based Lehman Brothers could have backfired unless the government stabilized the lending methods.  However as soon as January 2010, a representative of the Bank of Canada indicated that "if the Bank were to raise interest rates to cool the housing market" that the result would be like "dousing the entire nation's economy with cold water, just as it comes out from recession". Condo owners in Toronto are watching this extremely closely since a rise in lending rates would have a huge impact on condos for sale in downtown Toronto which would affect sales.

New figures published by the Canadian Real Estate Association this month indicate that there was a strong decrease in residential housing when the economic slowdown started in 2008. However this did not last long, and the recovery has not been as drastic as expected. Even though the May 2010 sales figures indicated a 9.5% drop, the year-over-year price gains actually balanced it to 8.4%.  This stabilization in the housing market is a normal outcome of buyers not being quite as anxious to invest as the supply of properties increases and prices climb slowly, but proportionately. While areas like Toronto can spare a small dip in values real estate in Hamilton may be harder hit as buyers sit on the sidelines.

Pascal Gauthier of the Toronto-Dominion Bank mentioned that the bubble situation "made a lot of people nervous," anticipating a huge crash comparable to the 30 percent drop in U.S. housing values. But he says this summer he is finding a "180-degree turn from six months ago," and that the temporary factors that boosted values have only translated in a modest fall in a sector that was clearly overvalued.  Even though the markets in Toronto and Vancouver may undergo a 7% drop that will bring down the national average, Gauthier believes they will carry most of of the decline, while regions like the Maritimes and The Prairies and may well find by the end of the year that they are experiencing gains once again.

About the Author:
Stefan Hyross is a housing blogger that studies the housing market. For news regarding Toronto properties or to search for condos for sale in downtown Toronto please go to the sites. You can also browse for Hamilton real estate and articles.
http://www.leabarclay.com/

Author: Stefan Hyross